John Derrick,
Mediator &
Arbitrator

John Derrick, Mediator & ArbitratorJohn Derrick, Mediator & ArbitratorJohn Derrick, Mediator & Arbitrator
  • Home
  • About
  • ADR Primer
  • Reasons
  • Rates
  • FAQs
  • Availability
  • Contact/Scheduling
  • More
    • Home
    • About
    • ADR Primer
    • Reasons
    • Rates
    • FAQs
    • Availability
    • Contact/Scheduling

John Derrick,
Mediator &
Arbitrator

John Derrick, Mediator & ArbitratorJohn Derrick, Mediator & ArbitratorJohn Derrick, Mediator & Arbitrator
  • Home
  • About
  • ADR Primer
  • Reasons
  • Rates
  • FAQs
  • Availability
  • Contact/Scheduling

ADR PRIMER

If you are a party to a dispute being litigated, or headed towards litigation, mediation offers significant benefits over fighting it out in court. Compared with litigation, mediation can bring speedy resolution at a fraction of the cost. And the parties control the outcome. The following tells you more about what it involves.


No longer so “alternative”


Mediation is often referred to as a form of “alternative dispute resolution,” or “ADR.” Today, however, mediation is very mainstream. All litigated disputes reach an outcome one way or another, but these days more civil cases are resolved through mediation than with court-imposed outcomes. Yet mediation is still an “alternative” to the traditional court system, and so the term “ADR” lives on.


Taking control of the outcome


One of the benefits of mediation is that it can bring closure to a dispute far more quickly than continued litigation. It can also save a lot of money in attorney fees. But perhaps the greatest benefit is that it empowers parties to control the outcome. Mediation gives parties the opportunity to decide for themselves how a case will be resolved, rather than having strangers — judges or jurors — make the decision for them. 

Mediation also provides for a resolution that can enable the parties to co-exist going forward. In some cases, the parties need not have anything further to do with each other no matter how a case ends. But in others, co-existence is important or, at least,  desirable. Even if a mediated outcome will not immediately heal existing wounds, it lays the ground for moving on more effectively than litigation where parties fight for an outcome with an eventual “winner” and “loser.” 


Mediation also allows for hedging bets. As strongly as people may feel about their case, litigation is inherently an uncertain process. The outcome can be very different from what a party expects. Often, neither side ends up satisfied with a litigated outcome.

Some people see mediation as being about reaching a “compromise.” But that word misses the mark. Yes, mediation involves negotiations. But mediation is really about reaching a good resolution for the parties given the circumstances they are in. The goal of a mediation is to identify a resolution that is better for both sides than continued litigation.


A voluntary process 


Courts can sometimes order the parties to mediate. But mediation is generally a voluntary process. And if you do mediate, you don’t have to reach an agreement. You can resume the litigation battle. 


Mediation vs. arbitration


People who are new to mediation sometimes confuse it with “arbitration,” which is another form of “alternative dispute resolution.” But the two processes are very different. An arbitrator imposes a decision, in much the same way as a judge does — except in a private proceeding outside of the court system. And, usually, that decision is binding on the parties under their agreement to arbitrate. But a mediator does not impose any outcomes. Rather, a mediator works with the parties to try to reach an Rather, a mediator works with the parties to try to reach an agreement about how to resolve a dispute.


What happens at a mediation


If you are new to mediation, you may be wondering exactly what it entails. An in-person mediation takes place at a location where each side has its own room. Mediation mostly involves the mediator spending time with each side — the parties and their lawyers — in separate sessions of varying lengths, listening to what they have to say and gradually exploring possible resolutions. It is the mediator’s role to create a safe space for the parties to engage in a process that is very different from what takes place in a courtroom.


Sometimes, the two sides meet at some point during the day in a joint session with the mediator, but that does not usually happen. However, caucuses involving the lawyers on the two sides meeting with the mediator without their clients are more common. 


Mediation confidentiality


Mediation is a confidential process. Nothing communicated in a mediation can be used in the continuing litigation if the case does not settle. And if a party tells the mediator something in a separate session — without the other side present — the mediator cannot share that without permission. These rules of confidentiality are sacrosanct and are an important reason why mediation can be so effective. Confidentiality allows the parties to try on ideas and explore outcomes without fearing they are somehow giving something up if no settlement is reached. 


Enforcing mediated settlements​


If the parties agree on a resolution, they then enter into a written settlement agreement, often before leaving the mediation. Assuming the settlement has been drafted properly, it is binding on the parties. That means it can be enforced in court. So while the process leading up to a settlement is entirely voluntary, a mediated resolution — once reached — is as certain and firm an outcome as one imposed by a court.


John Derrick serves on the Commercial and Consumer rosters of the American Arbitration Association. As an arbitrator, he fairly weighs the evidence and applies the law in a process that can be quicker and less expensive than litigation in the courts. The following tells you something about what arbitration involves.


Another court alternative


Arbitration — a form of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) — is a streamlined way of resolving a dispute when the parties are unable to agree on a settlement. Instead of having a court of law decide the case, the parties agree to have a private arbitrator do so.

Arbitration is an alternative to court, but it is not an alternative to mediation. You can do both. Many cases that are headed for resolution through arbitration settle by mediation along the way.


Some arbitrators — including John Derrick — also handle mediations as part of their ADR practice. Sometimes, a neutral acts as both mediator and arbitrator in the same case. But that can be problematic. For example, the parties may want to share certain things with a mediator they may not want to tell an arbitrator. So it generally makes sense to use a different neutral for the two roles.


Binding outcomes 


Most arbitration is binding. The arbitrator’s decision can be converted to a judgment in a court. It can then be fully enforced just like any other judgment.


Agreement required


Arbitration cannot take place without the agreement of the parties. Usually, the agreement to arbitrate was made long before the dispute arose, where an underlying contract provided for arbitration of any dispute in the future. Sometimes, though, the parties opt to arbitrate when a dispute arises where there was no pre-existing commitment.

In some cases, there can be a dispute as to whether an agreement to arbitrate was actually made or is enforceable. Issues of “arbitrability” can be complex and are litigated both in the courts and arbitration forums. Usually, however, arbitrability is not a factor. 


Arbitration forums


There are a number of ADR organizations that provide an infrastructure for arbitrations with rules of procedure as well as panels of qualified and vetted neutrals. These are sometimes referred to as “arbitration forums.” The largest is the American Arbitration Association — “AAA” or “Triple A” — a not-for-profit, public service organization, which has administered more than eight million ADR cases since its founding in 1926.


Contracts including an arbitration provision should specify an arbitration forum and, moreover, a specific set of rules used by that forum. Merely committing to arbitration without specifying any details can lead to too much uncertainty as to exactly what has been agreed. But an arbitration clause in an underlying contract can include much more than that. It might, for example, include a requirement to mediate in the first instance, as well as specifying the amount of discovery and other procedural ground rules.


Hearings


With some arbitrations, the proceeding involves only written evidence and argument. There is no “trial” with witnesses appearing in person. With others, however, there is a something similar to a trial, although it is generally referred to as an “evidentiary hearing.” This can take place in a conference room or — more commonly these days — by Zoom or some other videoconferencing platrform. There is preliminary hearing beforehand to settle the timeline and overall ground rules, and there may also be one or more status conferences before the evidentiary hearing.


Arbitration hearings tend to be more formal than mediations. For example, lawyers who might wear “business casual” to a mediation generally dress as though for court when attending an arbitration. Use of first names — common in mediations — may be discouraged in arbitrations. But arbitrations nonetheless lack some of the formalities of a courtroom. There is no “all rise” or anything like that.


Cost and time savings


Arbitration can be significantly less expensive than litigating in trial courts. It’s true that the parties pay the arbitrator a fee — generally based on time spent — whereas they don’t pay for a judge’s time (beyond modest court filing fees). And they also pay fees to the forum. But these are offset by the fact that arbitration procedures are much more streamlined than those in courts. There is usually only limited discovery. And there is much less by way of motions. So the types of activity that can rack up traditional litigation costs — and drag out the process — are substantially reduced.


Another benefit of arbitration is that the streamlined procedures result in the whole process taking much less time than a lawsuit in court. It’s not just that there is less pre-trial litigation. It’s also much easier to set a firm date for the evidentiary hearing. And — barring clear necessity — those dates generally stick. The culture is not one of constant continuances. In trial courts, by contrast, there are often significant backlogs making it very hard for parties to actually get their day in court.


By opting into arbitration, parties are asking for an efficient, streamlined dispute resolution process. And it is the arbitrator’s job to ensure they get what they bargained for.


Evidence in arbitrations


One of the main differences between a trial in a court and an evidentiary hearing in an arbitration is that, for the most part, the complex rules of evidence that apply in courts do not apply in arbitration. For example, an arbitrator will generally not exclude evidence based on hearsay or lack of foundation. That said, the arbitrator may give considerably less weight to such evidence. Generally, the only evidence that is excluded is that which violates a legally recognized privilege, such as attorney-client privilege.


One of the reasons why arbitrations involve liberal rules of evidence, and very limited — if any — scope for summary judgment or other forms of early dismissal, is to prevent courts from vacating an arbitration award. With arbitrations, there is generally no system of appealing a judgment on the basis of errors of law or lack of evidence. However, parties can petition a trial court to vacate an arbitration award on a narrow range of grounds, including the refusal by an arbitrator to hear material evidence relevant to the controversy. Therefore, to make awards robust to withstand judicial scrutiny, arbitrators want to ensure that parties cannot plausibly argue they were denied the opportunity to present pertinent and material evidence. And that means allowing them to put on the case they want.


The award


After a case is submitted following an evidentiary hearing, or the last of the written evidence or argument, the arbitrator typically issues a decision within 30 days. This is generally referred to as an “award” (even if nothing is actually awarded).


Some people think arbitrators are prone to split the difference and come up with compromise awards, in order to try to play to both galleries. But that is not how the system is meant to work. An arbitrator is meant to reach the right decision, not a compromise.


No appeals, but other safeguards 


As noted above, arbitrations do not generally allow the losing party to appeal (as opposed to seeking to vacate an award based on very narrow grounds, such as an arbitrator’s failure to disclose conflicts of interest or refusal to consider evidence). An exception is that some arbitration forums have their own internal appeal system that the parties can opt into at the outset. But these are not very common. And parties cannot challenge an arbitration award in an appellate court solely on grounds of legal error or insufficient evidence.


For some, that is a drawback of arbitration. But others see it as a benefit. Appeals in California typically take well over a year. And the vast majority do not result in any change in the outcome. So by cutting out the appeals process, arbitration forums deliver on their promise of efficient, expedited dispute resolution.


If the parties are worried about entrusting a decision to an arbitrator who might commit what — in a judicial setting — would be reversible error, there are safeguards. One is that parties can choose their arbitrator, assuming they can agree on one. In court, however, you don’t get to choose. Thus, litigants in court in a commercial case, for example, might get a judge who has little understanding of the subject matter, having only just gone on the bench after a career as a criminal prosecutor.


Another safeguard against judges making reversible error is that you can opt to have a panel of three arbitrators. That, obviously, increases costs and it generally only happens in larger, complex cases. But it does assuage the risk of putting too many eggs in one decision-making basket.


  • Availability

© 2026 John Derrick